tokenize - Why does SSIS TOKEN function fail to count adjacent column delimiters?

Question

I ran into a problem with SQL Server Integration Services 2012's new string function in the Expression Editor called TOKEN().

This is supposed to help you parse a delimited record. If the record comes out of a flat file, you can do this with the Flat File Source. In this case, I am dealing with old delimited import records that were stored as strings in a database VARCHAR field. Now they need to be extracted, massaged, and re-exported as delimited strings. For example:

1^Apple^0001^01/01/2010^Anteater^A1
2^Banana^0002^03/15/2010^Bear^B2
3^Cranberry^0003^4/15/2010^Crow^C3

If these strings are in a column called OldImportRecord, the delimiter is a caret (as shown), and we wish to put the fifth field into a Derived Column, we would use an expression like:

TOKEN(OldImportRecord,"^",5)

This returns Anteater, Bear, Crow, etc. In fact, we can create Derived Columns for each of the fields in this record (note that the index is one-based), change them as needed, and then build another delimited record for export.

Here's the problem. What if some of our data includes some empty strings (or Nulls rendered as empty strings)?

4^^0004^6/15/2010^Duck^D4

The TOKEN() fails to count the adjacent column delimiters, which throws off the column count. Now it only sees five columns instead of six columns. Our TOKEN(OldImportRecord,"^",5) returns "D4" instead of the intended "Duck". When we extract the fourth column, we wind up trying to put "Duck" into a Date column, and all sorts of fun ensues.

Here's a partial workaround:

TOKEN(REPLACE(OldImportRecord,"^^","^ ^"),"^",5)

Notice this misses every second delimiter pair, so it will fail for a string like "5^^^^Emu^E5", which looks like"5^ ^^ ^Emu^E5" after the REPLACE(). The column count is still wrong.

So here's my full workaround. This includes two nested REPLACE statements(), an RTRIM() to remove the superfluous spaces, and a DT_STR cast because I would like to keep the result in VARCHAR:

(DT_STR,255,1252)RTRIM(TOKEN(REPLACE(REPLACE(OldImportRecord,"^^","^ ^"),"^^","^ ^"),"^",5))

I am posting this for information, since others may also run into this problem.

Does anyone have a better workaround, or even a real solution?

Answer 1

Reason for the issue:

TOKEN method in SSIS uses the implementation of strtok function in C++. I gathered this information while reading the book Microsoft? SQL Server? 2012 Integration Services. It is mentioned as note on page 113 (I like this book! Lots of nice information.).

I searched for the implementation of strtok function and I found the following links.

INFO: strtok(): C Function -- Documentation Supplement - The code sample in this link shows that the function does ignore consecutive delimiter characters.

The answers to the following SO questions point out that strtok function is designed to ignore consecutive delimiters.

Need to know when no data appears between two token separators using strtok()

strtok_s behaviour with consecutive delimiters

I think that the TOKEN and TOKENCOUNT functions are working as per design but whether that is how SSIS should behave might be a question for the Microsoft SSIS team.

Original Post - Above section is an update:

I created a simple package in SSIS 2012 based on your data inputs. As you had described in your question, the TOKEN function does not behave as intended. I agree with you that the function doesn't seem to work. This post is not an answer to your original issue.

Here is an alternative way to write the expression in a relatively simpler fashion. This will only work if the last segment in your input record will always have a value (say A1, B2, C3 etc.).

Expression can be rewritten as:

This statement will take the input record as the parameter, the delimiter caret (^) as the second parameter. The third parameter calculates the total number segments in the records when split by the delimiter. If you have data in the last segment, you are guaranteed to have two segments. You can then subtract 1 to fetch the penultimate segment.

(DT_STR,50,1252)TOKEN(OldImportRecord,"^",TOKENCOUNT(OldImportRecord,"^") - 1)

I created a simple package with data flow task. OLE DB source retrieves the data and the derived transformation parses and splits the data as per the screenshot below. The output is then inserted into the destination table. You can see the source and destination tables in the last screenshot. Destination table has two columns. The first column stores the penultimate segment data and the segments count based on the delimiter (which again isn't correct). You can notice that the last record didn't fetch the correct results. If the last record didn't have the value 8, then the above expression will fail because the expression will evaluate to zero index.

Hope that helps to simplify your expression.

If you don't hear from anyone else, I would recommend logging this issue in Microsoft Connect website.

Create table and populate scripts:

CREATE TABLE [dbo].[SourceTable](
    [OldImportRecord] [varchar](50) NOT NULL
) ON [PRIMARY]
GO

CREATE TABLE [dbo].[DestinationTable](
    [NewImportRecord] [varchar](50) NOT NULL,
    [CaretCount] [int] NOT NULL
) ON [PRIMARY]
GO

INSERT INTO dbo.SourceTable (OldImportRecord) VALUES 
    ('1^Apple^0001^01/01/2010^Anteater^A1'),
    ('2^Banana^0002^03/15/2010^Bear^B2'),
    ('3^Cranberry^0003^4/15/2010^Crow^C3'),
    ('4^^0004^6/15/2010^Duck^D4'),
    ('5^^^^Emu^E5'),
    ('6^^^^Geese^F6'),
    ('^^^^Pheasant^G7'),
    ('8^^^^Sparrow^');
GO

Derived column transformation inside data flow task:

Data in source and destination tables: