c++ - C++11 inheriting constructors and access modifiers

Question

Assuming the following layout:

class Base
{
protected:
    Base(P1 p1, P2 p2, P3 p3);

public:
    virtual void SomeMethod() = 0;
}

class Derived : public Base
{
public:
    using Base::Base;

public:
    virtual void SomeMethod() override;
};

Should I be able to specify Derived's constructor as public here? VC++ gives the following error:

cannot access protected member declared in class 'Derived'
compiler has generated 'Derived::Derived' here [points to the using Base::Base line]
see declaration of 'Derived'

i.e. it's ignoring the access modifier above the inherited constructor.

Is this a limitation of the feature? It doesn't make any sense for the Base class to have a public constructor, as it can never be instantiated directly (due to the pure virtual method).

question from:https://stackoverflow.com/questions/21015909/c11-inheriting-constructors-and-access-modifiers

Answer 1

According to 12.9/4, "Inheriting constructors", when saying using X::X,

A constructor so declared has the same access as the corresponding constructor in X.

So the inherited constructor is also protected.