java - What is the difference between a "Spring transaction" and a "Hibernate transaction"

Question

Could you please explain the difference between the following two types of transactions:

1. Hibernate transaction
2. Spring transaction

Also I would like to know about the @Transactional annotation.

Answer 1

Well for starters they are both Transactions, but they encompass different concepts and components.

TL;DR

Hibernate deals with database specific transactions, whereas spring provides a general transaction management service. @Transactional is a nice way of configuring transaction management behaviour.

The long story:

Transactions

Transactions are basically units of work (ie changes to something) that are managed as a single operation that can be either committed or rolled back. There are lots of different types of transactions in the java world - database, messaging systems like JMS, inter application transactions (for those who are not faint of heart) or anything else that may need to be included in a transaction. In the Java standard transactions are managed using the Java Transaction API which sets the rules for how to participate in a transaction.

Hibernate

Hibernate is an ORM for abstracting database components to Java objects, so its transactions are specifically related to changes made within a database. A transaction may be made up of one or many writes to various database tables that are all committed once the operation is completed. Rolling back the transaction, eg f there are any errors during the operation, allows all the changes to be undone.

Spring

At its lowest level Spring is a application framework for managing configuration and dependencies between objects. In addition it also provides an interface for managing higher level services that are used in modern applications such as databases, messaging services, MVC frameworks and transactions.

Spring is designed to be used as an all-encompassing master of objects and services within your application, so its concept of a transaction is at a higher level than the database specific transactions that hibernate concerns itself with. Spring Transactions are designed to give you fine grained control of all your transactional resources while abstracting away the often messy coding required to co-ordinate the transactions.

@Transactional

Spring provides a few different methods for using transactions - among others there xml based aspects, coding to the API and annotation based declarative transactions. The annotation based transactions are handy because you dont need to add the transaction management boilerplate code to your app (even using PlatformTransactionManager via the API has quite a bit of coding overhead).

So basically what happens with @Transactional is that at runtime spring scans your code base for @Transactional classes and methods and wraps them up in the transaction specific management code, based on what you have configured via the annotation. So a method like this:

@Transactional(propagation = REQUIRES_NEW, rollbackFor = {Exception.class})
public void saveAndSendMessage(Foo foo) throws Exception {
    dbManager.save(foo);
    Bar bar = transform(foo);
    jmsSystem.send(bar);
}  

can have spring set up a new transaction for the database and jms system, and co-ordinate them without needing to add all the specific tx management code automagically.