scala - Combining Futures, Eithers and Options in for comprehensions

Question

I have a collection of methods that return different types:

Either[ErrorResponse, X]
Future[Either[ErrorResponse, X]]
Option[ErrorResponse]

These methods need the result from a previous method to perform their computation. The methods:

type Parameters = Map[String, String]

// allows me to flatmap on an either
implicit def toRightProjection[Failure, Success](e: Either[Failure, Success]) =
  e.right

// converts anything to a future
implicit def toFuture[T](t: T) =
  Future.successful(t)

// retrieves the request paramters from the given request
def requestParameters(request: RequestHeader): Either[ErrorResponse, Parameters] = ???

// retrieves the response type from the given parameters
def responseType(p: Parameters): Either[ErrorResponse, String] = ???

// retrieves the client id from the given parameters
def clientId(p: Parameters): Either[ErrorResponse, String] = ???

// retrieves the client using the given client id
def client(clientId: String): Future[Either[ErrorResponse, Client]] = ???

// validates the response type of the client
def validateResponseType(client: Client, responseType: String): Option[ErrorResponse] = ???

I can the wire them together with the following for comprehension (note that I wrote down some types to clarify the contents of specific parts of the computation).

val result: Either[ErrorResponse, Future[Either[ErrorResponse, Client]]] =
  for {
    parameters <- requestParameters(request)
    clientId <- clientId(parameters)
    responseType <- responseType(parameters)
  } yield {
    val result: Future[Either[ErrorResponse, Either[ErrorResponse, Client]]] =
      for {
        errorOrClient <- client(clientId)
        client <- errorOrClient
      } yield validateResponseType(client, responseType).toLeft(client)

    result.map(_.joinRight)
  }

val wantedResult: Future[Either[ErrorResponse, Client]] =
  result.left.map(Future successful Left(_)).merge

The above code is quite messy and I feel this can be done differently. I read about monads and monad transformers. The concept of those is very new to me and I can not get my head around it.

Most of the examples only deal with two types of results: Either[X, Y] and Future[Either[X, Y]]. I still find it very hard to bend my mind around it.

How can I write a nice and clean for comprehension that replaces the above one?

Something like this would be awesome (I am not sure if that is even possible):

val result: Future[Either[ErrorResponse, Client]] =
  for {
    parameters <- requestParameters(request)
    clientId <- clientId(parameters)
    responseType <- responseType(parameters)
    client <- client(clientId)
    _ <- validateResponseType(client, responseType)
  }

Answer 1

OK, here is my attempt at this:

import scalaz._, Scalaz._

implicit val futureMonad = new Monad[Future] {
  override def point[A](a: ? A): Future[A] = future(a)

  override def bind[A, B](fa: Future[A])(f: A ? Future[B]): Future[B] =
    fa.flatMap(f)
}

import EitherT._
val result: EitherT[Future, ErrorResponse, Client] =
  for {
    parameters <- fromEither(Future(requestParameters(request)))
    clientId <- fromEither(Future(clientId(parameters)))
    responseType <- fromEither(Future(responseType(parameters)))
    client <- fromEither(client(clientId))
    response <- fromEither[Future, ErrorResponse, Client](Future(validateResponseType(client, responseType).toLeft(client)))
  } yield response

val x: Future[/[ErrorResponse, Client]] = result.run