rest - How to protect RESTful API

Question

I have been looking for a way to protect my RESTful APIs. This appeared simple, but it seems to not be so simple. First off, I am writing an iOS app connecting to a Play Framework server. None of this has anything to do with Google, Facebook, Twitter, or LinkedIn (shocking I know). Oh, and my current plans do not require custom apps to use my APIs, its just my apps for the time being.

Basic Authentication

What appeared to be simple was a basic user/pass on a /auth method managing a cookie session. That may draw some groans as being too simple or weak but mostly it moved identity to a session key quickly verified. My initial setup was to expire the sessions every day, but that lead to the iOS app forcing a login daily proving to be an annoyance.

OAuth

I posted a question on an iOS board and received a blunt direction towards OAuth. My research of OAuth began but holy sh*t is that complicated and there does not seem to be any server side examples... just plenty of people complaining about how frustrating it is. All the client examples show connecting to Google, Facebook, Twitter, and LinkedIn. Oh Joy!

After watching Eran Hammer's rant about OAuth1 and OAuth2, it seemed fruitless to continue and his OZ idea (which looks really clean) is only at the early stages in node.js.

Question

So, my question to the broad StackOverflow community is... what do you do for securing your REST APIs?

Answer 1

I'd suggest to consider approach used by biggest players i.e. Amazon Web Services or Windows Azure - HMAC. Although it isn't comfortable in implementation, as you can see it's trusted technique.

The general idea is to sign the request's parts (i.e. headers) in the iOS with secret key and try to recalculate it on the Play app to verify that request is authentic and not manipulated. If it won't fail, you can be (almost) sure, that was sent from somebody, who uses valid secret key.

Take a look into Windows' document to get the concept (I think that for common task, you can use the less number of elements used for signing).

There is also other interesting post (based on AWS authentication) which describes whole process even better.

Edit

Of course you should realize that authentication in iOS and securing API requests are different things, even if you'll expire your session every 15 minutes, you can't be sure that somebody won't overhear it and then will be able to send a fake request from the outside. Signing every request should minimize the risk.

On the other hand, if you'll prepare clear rules for signing the requests and will write short doc (which I recommend even for yourself), you can deliver it to the other developer and he'll be able to implement it in (almost) any platform supporting SHA256, so you will have API ready for using from 3-rd party apps - if you'll decide to publish it in the future.